Civitella et al. [16] | 2023 | RCT | N = 60, radical prostatectomy, US-TAP (n = 30) or LAP-TAP (n = 30). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications, LOS. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications, or LOS between groups. |
Diyaolu et al. [17] | 2021 | RCT | N = 50, pediatric laparoscopic procedures, US-TAP (n = 25) or LAP-TAP (n = 25). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, block completion time. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between groups. Blocks were faster in the LAP-TAP group compared to the US-TAP group (2.1 ± 1.9 min vs. 7.9 ± 3.4 min, p < 0.001). |
Doble et al. [18] | 2018 | Retrospective review | N = 39, hernia repair, US-TAP (n = 17) or LAP-TAP (n = 22). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, LOS. | Post-op pain score (2.35 vs. 4.18, p = 0.019) and opioid consumption during hospitalization (408.52 vs. 860.92 mg; p = 0.013) were lower in the LAP-TAP group compared to the US-TAP group. No significant difference in LOS between groups. |
Emile et al. [19] | 2022 | RCT | N = 110, laparoscopic cholecystectomy, US-TAP (n = 36), LAP-TAP (n = 36), or no TAP (n = 38). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications. | US-TAP and LAP-TAP groups had lower pain scores and opioid consumption compared to the no TAP group. No significant differences between US-TAP and LAP-TAP groups. No complications reported in any group. |
La Regina et al. [20] | 2023 | RCT | N = 112, colorectal surgery, US-TAP (n = 57) or LAP-TAP (n = 55). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications, LOS. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications, or LOS between groups. |
Landmann et al. [21] | 2018 | Retrospective review | N = 330, pediatric cases, US-TAP (n = 125), LAP-TAP (n = 88), or local wound infiltration (n = 117). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, LOS. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between groups. LAP-TAP group demonstrated a shorter LOS compared to the other groups (p = 0.02). |
McDonald et al. [22] | 2022 | RCT | N = 78, gynecology oncology cases, US-TAP (n = 39), or LAP-TAP (n = 39). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption. | No difference in pain scores between groups. Significant increase in opioid consumption among LAP-TAP group compared to US-TAP group in first 24 hr post-op (p = 0.018). |
Narasimhulu et al. [23] | 2018 | RCT | N = 41, cesarean sections, US-TAP (n = 21), or LAP-TAP (n = 20). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, block completion time. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between groups. Block completion time was significantly less for the LAP-TAP group compared to the US-TAP group (2.4 vs. 12.1 min, p <0.001). |
Paasch et al. [24] | 2020 | Retrospective review | N = 116, inguinal hernia repair, US-TAP (n = 58) or LAP-TAP (n = 58). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between groups. |
Park et al. [25] | 2017 | RCT | N = 80, laparoscopic colectomy, US-TAP (n = 40), or LAP-TAP (n = 40). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between groups. |
Ravichandran et al. [26] | 2017 | RCT | N = 60, laparoscopic cholecystectomy, US-TAP (n = 30), or LAP-TAP (n = 30). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, block completion time. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between groups. Block completion time was significantly less for the LAP-TAP group compared to the US-TAP group (p < 0.05). |
Sahap et al. [27] | 2023 | RCT | N = 63, laparoscopic cholecystectomy, US-TAP (n = 21), LAP-TAP (n = 21), or no TAP (n = 21). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between the US-TAP and LAP-TAP groups. Pain scores were significantly lower in the US-TAP and LAP-TAP groups compared to the no TAP group (p < 0.05). |
Sharma et al. [28] | 2023 | RCT | N = 122, bariatric surgery, US-TAP (n = 60), or LAP-TAP (n = 62). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, block completion time, cost of performing block. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores or opioid consumption between groups. LAP-TAP had shorter block completion time compared to US-TAP (3.58 min vs. 12.47 min, p < 0.01). The cost of US-TAP was USD 50 greater, on average, than that of LAP-TAP. |
Soyturk el al. [29] | 2023 | RCT | N = 170, laparoscopic cholecystectomy, US-TAP (n = 55), LAP-TAP (n = 59), or no TAP (n = 56). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption. | The US-TAP and LAP-TAP groups had lower pain scores and opioid consumption compared to the no TAP group. Pain scores 1 and 12 h post-op were higher in the US-TAP group compared to the LAP-TAP group (p < 0.001). No significant differences in opioid consumption between US-TAP and LAP-TAP groups. |
Urfalioglu et al. [30] | 2017 | RCT | N = 75, cesarean section, US-TAP (n = 38), or LAP-TAP (n = 37). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications, block completion time. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, or complications between groups. Average block completion time was longer in the US-TAP group than in the LAP-TAP group (10 min vs. 7 min). |
Venkatraman et al. [31] | 2020 | RCT | N = 80, laparoscopic cholecystectomy, US-TAP (n = 40) or LAP-TAP (n = 40). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores between groups. Post-op opioid consumption was less in the US-TAP group than in the LAP-TAP group (p = 0.049). |
Wong et al. [32] | 2020 | RCT | N = 60, laparoscopic colectomies, US-TAP (n = 31), or LAP-TAP (n = 29). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, or complications between groups. |
Zaghiyan et al. [33] | 2019 | RCT | N = 107, laparoscopic colorectal surgery, US-TAP (n = 45), LAP-TAP (n = 41), or no TAP (n = 21). | Post-op pain scores, opioid consumption, complications, LOS. | No significant difference in post-op pain scores, complications, or LOS between all groups. The LAP-TAP group had less post-op opioid consumption compared to both the US-TAP (p = 0.007) and no TAP (p = 0.007) groups. |