Leveraging Advanced Technologies for (Smart) Transportation Planning: A Systematic Review


Guan et al. (2016) [24]Urban transport systems (Guangzhou, China)
  • Deployment of an intelligent transportation system (ITS) for traffic flow optimization and decision support

  • Enhanced traffic management systems (e.g., signal control, event monitoring, emergency rescue, and electronic toll collection, dynamic navigation, parking information services, etc.)

  • Geographic Information System (GIS)-based decision support system for data management and analysis

  • Integration of advanced information technology, data communication, electronic sensors, control systems, and computing technologies for real-time traffic management

  • Use of panel data for statistical analyses to evaluate transportation system performance

Chen et al. (2017) [25]Rural contexts (Quinte West, Southeastern Ontario, Canada)
  • Inequitable access to essential services for rural populations, including healthcare and groceries

  • Rising operational costs for demand-responsive transport systems

  • Scarce resources and difficulty balancing multiple objectives, such as cost, coverage, and equity

  • GIS-based decision support system for data management and analysis

  • Redesigned bus routes optimized for equity and cost

  • Applied a heuristic procedure for route optimization balancing cost and equity

  • GIS for mapping population density and major points of interest across rural regions

  • Data envelopment analysis (DEA) for multi-objective optimization and efficiency assessment

  • Multi-objective utility analysis (MOUA) and conjoint analysis for equity evaluation

  • Dijkstra algorithm for path optimization

Ata et al. (2019) [26]Highway/Arterial networks (England, UK)
  • Increasing vehicular density leading to congestion

  • Failure of classical approaches to ensure smooth and efficient traffic flow due to rising urban traffic demands

  • Adverse weather conditions affecting road traffic and safety

  • Ineffectiveness of conventional traffic management solutions in managing increasing vehicular density

  • Dynamic congestion prediction using artificial neural networks (ANNs)

  • Real-time adjustments to signal timings based on congestion levels

  • Weather-integrated traffic management to enhance road safety and reduce delays

  • Back Propagation Neural Networks (BPNN) for predicting traffic delays with input-output mapping

  • Levenberg–Marquardt algorithm for training multilayer perceptron networks with dataset division

  • Smart traffic control system architecture

  • Non-Linear Autoregressive with External Input (NARX) model for time-series traffic data analysis and simulation using MATLAB R2017a

  • IoT-based data acquisition from sensors deployed at intersections for real-time traffic monitoring and control

Babar & Arif (2019) [27]Simulated environments (based on the data from Aarhus City, Denmark)
  • Traffic congestion caused by insufficient real-time data processing

  • Challenges in integrating heterogeneous IoT data sources for transportation

  • High computational demands for managing large-scale data

  • Real-time data analysis for traffic flow prediction and congestion management

  • Dynamic decision-making using real-time event detection and response systems

  • Development of a smart transportation system architecture using big data analytics for real-time processing

  • Utilization of Apache Hadoop for large-scale data storage and processing

  • MapReduce programming for parallel processing mechanism to manage large datasets efficiently

  • IoT integration using traffic sensors, cameras, and GPS data aggregation for real-time monitoring

  • Noise reduction in data using statistical methods like Kalman filters

Luo et al. (2019) [28]Urban transport systems (Shenyang, China)
  • Need for integration of real-time data to reduce uncertainty and improve response

  • Severe traffic congestion due to rapid urbanization and economic growth

  • Inefficiency in traditional public transport scheduling due to static timetables

  • Passenger dissatisfaction caused by long waiting times and irregular bus services

  • Unpredictable traffic conditions impacting resource allocation and vehicle routing

  • Real-time passenger flow analysis and vehicle control optimization

  • Dynamic dispatching of buses based on real-time traffic and passenger data

  • Transport flow prediction using periodic pattern mining

  • Decision support system with evolutionary algorithms for scheduling optimization

  • IoT-based framework which includes perception, network, and application layers

  • Sensors for GPS tracking, automatic passenger counting, and real-time traffic monitoring

  • Communication protocols like GSM, 4G, Zigbee, and Wi-Fi

  • Dynamic scheduling and optimization applications

  • Cloud computing for data processing and analysis

  • Optimization algorithms for vehicle dispatching

  • Meta-heuristic algorithms for complex scheduling problems

Nallaperuma et al. (2019) [29]Highway/Arterial networks (Victoria, Australia)
  • Real-time handling of dynamic and volatile traffic data streams

  • Lack of real-time machine learning algorithms to predict non-recurrent traffic incidents across entire road networks

  • Predicting traffic flow under diverse, evolving conditions

  • Deep learning approach for real-time traffic flow prediction and impact propagation estimation across arterial road networks

  • Deep reinforcement learning model to optimize traffic control actions using real-time data

  • Social media data integration model to capture commuter sentiment and emotions during non-recurrent traffic events

  • Bluetooth traffic monitoring system for trajectory data collection at arterial road junctions

  • Online learning techniques to manage high-volume and high-velocity data with data-driven processing triggers

  • Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) for forecasting traffic flow and identifying critical road segments

  • Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) for adaptive and intelligent traffic control systems

  • Long short-term memory (LSTM) architecture for capturing temporal traffic patterns

  • Sentiment analysis of social media data, extending traditional methods to extract deeper emotions

Shengdong et al. (2019) [30]Simulated environments (based on data from California, USA)
  • Integration of cloud computing, network control systems, and traffic management to provide technical support for traffic control

  • Edge computing to provide localized control for critical nodes in the ITS

  • Development of an intelligent transportation cyber-physical cloud control system for real-time data management and control

  • Traffic redistribution strategies to alleviate congestion in overburdened areas

  • Utilization of cloud computing for scalable traffic flow prediction, optimization, and scheduling

  • Cyber-physical systems (CPS) for acquisition, transmission, and computation of traffic data in real time for the optimization, decision making, scheduling, planning, prediction, and control of the system

  • Traffic big data analytics for advanced data mining techniques for accurate and efficient traffic data processing

  • Deep Belief Network-Support Vector Regression (DBN-SVR) for large datasets

  • Back Propagation Bilateral Extreme Learning Machine (BP-BELM) for small-scale predictions

  • Edge computing for real-time, localized control

  • Cloud systems for large-scale computation and data storage

Dauletbak & Woo (2020) [31]Highway/Arterial networks (Los Angeles County, California, USA)
  • Severe congestion at key locations and during peak times

  • Insufficient predictive tools for identifying long-term traffic patterns

  • Data imbalance affecting accurate predictions of extreme congestion levels

  • Predictive analytics for classifying jam severity and supporting real-time traffic management

  • Identification of traffic hotspots and peak times for infrastructure planning

  • Enhanced visualization for dynamic traffic analysis

  • Navigation app data captured at millisecond intervals, providing raw traffic datasets for analysis

  • Hadoop big data system for storing and processing large-scale traffic datasets using distributed parallel computing

  • Hive ecosystem with HiveQL for data schema creation, cleaning, summarization, and sample dataset generation

  • Multiclass Decision Forest for classification of jam levels

  • Interactive visuals to illustrate traffic jams, time-based trends, and segmented information for better analysis

Chen et al. (2021) [32]Highway/Arterial networks (Taiwan)
  • High variability in freight travel time due to stochastic events (e.g., congestion, weather)

  • Lack of robust short-term predictive models for real-time logistics

  • Difficulties in processing large-scale, heterogeneous IoT data in real-time

  • Data-driven predictive analytics combining real-time traffic data with stochastic modeling to enhance travel time reliability

  • Adaptive logistics management by integrating predictive analytics into routing and scheduling

  • Enhanced response speed and operational efficiency in Logistics 4.0

  • Traffic IoT integrating big data sources for logistics and transportation system improvements

  • Traffic sensors, GPS, and vehicle detectors

  • 5G-enabled Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) for seamless connectivity and data exchange in transportation systems

  • Ensemble machine learning techniques, such as bagging and boosting, to enhance model performance by combining multiple predictors

Lemonde et al. (2021) [33]Regional transport systems (Lisbon Metropolitan Area, Portugal)
  • Lack of integration of multimodal traffic data with situational context for improved mobility management

  • Insufficient context-aware analysis to capture situational dynamics (e.g., large-scale events, traffic restrictions, weather, and urban planning changes) on mobility patterns

  • Context-aware and multimodal traffic analysis principles for integrating urban data sources

  • Spatiotemporal and contextual modeling for emerging traffic trends and system optimization

  • Predictive traffic analysis using deep learning models such as recurrent neural networks and graph neural networks (GNNs) for short-term and long-term forecasting

  • Integration of automated fare collection systems to track cross-carrier passenger flows and infer comprehensive origin-destination matrices

  • Urban data fusion techniques to enhance data consistency and completeness

  • Machine learning and analytics for predictive, prescriptive, and diagnostic analysis of multimodal traffic data

  • Spatiotemporal pattern mining and relational data mining techniques for understanding user-specific mobility patterns

  • Deployment of reinforcement learning and deep neural networks for optimizing public transport operations

  • Scenario-based simulation approaches to support decision-making in traffic management

  • Traffic dashboards and GIS-based multimodal data representation

Muntean (2021) [34]Urban transport systems (Birmingham, UK)
  • Processing and analyzing large volumes of smart city data for timely decision-making

  • Traffic congestion and crowded parking due to high vehicle density and limited space

  • Inefficiency in traffic light operations

  • Real-time traffic forecasting for flow optimization

  • Automated traffic management mechanism to prevent congestion and optimize urban mobility

  • Decision trees for fault detection and rapid decision-making

  • Parking occupancy prediction to assist in space allocation

  • Multi-agent system (MAS) architecture designed for urban traffic management processes

  • K-nearest neighbor (KNN) for occupancy rates and Random Tree for traffic flow

  • Monitoring agents equipped with expert systems using the Jess rule engine for anomaly detection

  • Implementation within the Java Agent Development Framework (JADE) for inter-agent communication

  • Data mining tool for forecasting, classification, data pre-processing, and visualization

Rathore et al. (2021) [35]Urban transport systems (Aarhus, Denmark, Madrid, Spain, and Cologne, Germany)
  • Traffic congestion due to increased urbanization and vehicle density

  • Inefficient traffic management caused by the inability to process real-time data effectively

  • Delays in routing decisions for commuters and emergency services

  • Real-time traffic analysis to identify congested routes and redistribute traffic

  • Traffic flow analysis using periodic pattern mining

  • Smart routing for commuters and emergency services using weighted graphs

  • Data-driven decision-making for urban planners to design better traffic systems

  • CPS, which integrates IoT sensors and big data tools for real-time data collection and analysis

  • Graph algorithms that utilized Dijkstra’s algorithm and maximum spanning tree techniques for traffic route optimization

  • Big data tools using Apache Spark 2.3.1 GraphX and Hadoop 2.6.5 for big data processing

Sahil (2021) [36]Simulated environments (used systematically generated synthetic datasets)
  • Adaptive green light scheduling based on real-time traffic inflow data

  • Smart navigation system to guide vehicles along time-optimized routes and evenly distribute traffic across available paths

  • Real-time situation-aware traffic management to enhance road safety and improve overall traffic flow

  • IoT for acquiring vehicle mobility data through onboard sensors, infrastructure-based sensors, and vehicle-to-infrastructure communication via Vehicular Ad-hoc Networks (VANETs)

  • Edge computing for low-latency, location-aware, and real-time processing of mobility data

  • Cloud computing for data storage and large-scale processing of traffic data

  • The reverse edge layer facilitates time-efficient smart navigation, ensuring the optimal distribution

Yu et al. (2021) [37]Simulated environments (based on data from Jiangsu University, China)
  • Safety risks in mixed traffic environments with autonomous and manual vehicles

  • Poor real-time performance and low accuracy in intention recognition systems

  • Limited data processing capabilities in traditional ITS frameworks

  • 5G, edge computing, and AI-based deep learning traffic safety solution for mixed traffic

  • Use of normalized driving trajectory and natural-driving datasets

  • Decision-level fusion of historical and natural-driving data for higher recognition accuracy

  • 5G technology for data collection and edge processing without centralized servers

  • TensorFlow framework for building long short-term memory networks

  • Moving average algorithm for smoothing driving trajectory data

  • LSTM network to handle data dependence and time sequence issues

  • Edge computing to support decentralized data processing, reducing the load on centralized servers

Bachechi et al. (2022) [38]Urban transport systems (Modena, Italy, and Santiago de Compostela, Spain)
  • Traffic congestion impacts air quality and urban livability

  • Lack of tools for integrating traffic and pollution data in real-time

  • Sensor data anomalies reduce reliability for traffic modeling

  • Trafair Traffic Dashboard to analyze and visualize real-time traffic sensor data and traffic flow simulations

  • Integration of traffic modeling with air quality impact analysis to provide actionable insights for city administrations

  • Scenario-based simulations to evaluate sustainable urban policies

  • Microscopic traffic simulations and route generation from sensor data

  • Data cleaning using speed-flow correlation filters and anomaly detection with Seasonal-Trend Decomposition using Loess and Interquartile Range analysis

  • PostgreSQL database with PostGIS and Timescale extensions for efficient spatial and temporal data management

  • Anomaly detection algorithms applied to sensor data

Brazález et al. (2022) [39]Urban transport systems (Madrid, Spain)
  • Balancing mobility with health restrictions during a pandemic

  • Computing safe and fast routes considering changing alert levels and curfews

  • Integrating diverse data sources for decision-making

  • Real-time computation of routes based on health data and mobility restrictions

  • Dynamic alert-level-based traffic control for urban areas

  • Modular architecture allowing easy adaptation to other emergencies

  • Complex Event Processing (CEP) to detect real-time events and health risks using tools like MEdit4CEP

  • Fuzzy Inference System implemented to facilitate traffic restriction decisions

  • Colored Petri Net (CPN) models to mapping for route simulations, integrating alert levels and time restrictions

  • Deployment of the Pandemic intelligent transportation system to support authorities in making mobility decisions and ensuring efficient routing for drivers

Chen et al. (2023) [40]Urban transport systems (Taiwan)
  • High variability and unpredictability of travel times due to traffic congestion, accidents, and roadwork

  • Inadequate performance of traditional predictive models under dynamic traffic conditions

  • Growing emphasis on green transportation necessitates efficient logistics and transportation planning

  • Bi-directional time processing for enhanced predictive accuracy

  • Real-time vehicle routing optimization using predicted travel times

  • Integration of IoT data for continuous updates and system improvement

  • Bi-Directional Isometric-Gated Recurrent Unit (BDIGRU) for chronological and retrospective information processing

  • IoT-based terminal technology for collecting vehicle operation and road condition data

  • Machine learning-based gradient descent optimization for real-time analytics

  • Integration of traffic data processing with enterprise resource management for cost-effective logistics optimization

Kušić et al. (2023) [41]Highway/Arterial networks (Geneva, Switzerland)
  • Inability of traditional traffic simulations to adapt to real-time changes

  • Ineffective testing of control strategies like variable speed limits in offline models

  • Difficulty in developing control strategies that perform consistently across varying traffic states in dynamic and stochastic environments such as motorways

  • Development of a run-time synchronized digital twin model of the Geneva motorway using real-time traffic data from motorway counters

  • Safe and efficient testing of traffic management strategies using parallel Digital Twin Instances (DTIs)

  • Predictive analytics for early detection of traffic anomalies and optimization of traffic flows

  • Leveraging the open data and the microscopic traffic emulator to enhance simulation capabilities

  • Simulation of Urban Mobility (SUMO) for modeling and simulating synchronized digital replicas of real motorway traffic

  • Dynamic Flow Calibration mechanism for real-time adjustment of traffic flow distributions

  • Real-time data collection from motorway traffic counters aggregated every minute and accessed via the Open Data Platform Mobility Switzerland (ODPMS)

  • Use of a central repository for storing and accessing high-resolution traffic data for real-time simulations

Montero-Lamas et al. (2023) [42]Urban transport systems (Coruña, Spain)
  • Increased bus travel times due to mixed traffic conditions

  • Delays caused by general traffic, ridership levels, and weather factors

  • Inefficiencies in calculating passenger time savings with traditional methods

  • Exclusive bus lanes to mitigate traffic interference and reduce travel times

  • Utilizing sensor and management system data with high spatial and temporal detail to enhance analysis

  • Enhanced methodologies for calculating passenger time savings using big data

  • Alighting prediction algorithms to improve ridership data accuracy

  • Bluetooth sensors for traffic flow and travel times

  • Inductive loops for road occupancy and flow rate

  • Statistical methods tailored to fit specific case studies for improved accuracy

Rani & Sharma (2023) [43]Simulated environments (used the CIC-IDS2017 dataset)
  • Managing heterogeneous IoT traffic from interconnected devices in transportation networks

  • Effective network monitoring and management for Internet of Vehicles (IoV) systems

  • Preventing traffic congestion by utilizing ITS data for proactive forecasting

  • Security threats such as intrusions and attacks on vehicular networks

  • Development of an intelligent intrusion detection system (IDS) for IoV-based vehicular networks using tree-based machine learning and ensemble learning techniques

  • Stacked ensemble learning approach for improved accuracy in intrusion detection

  • Feature selection to optimize network monitoring and reduce computational costs

  • Enhancing accuracy and attack detection capability

  • Application of machine learning-based IDS for IoV within vehicular ad hoc networks

  • Use of tree-based learning techniques such as Decision Tree, Random Forest, Extra Tree, and XGBoost for classification and training

  • Stacking methodology to enhance classifier robustness and reliability by combining multiple learners

Tao et al. (2023) [44]Urban transport systems (Hong Kong)
  • Traffic flow prediction models for real-time signal optimization and dynamic routing

  • Ensemble learning methods to improve the accuracy of traffic flow predictions

  • Optimizing traffic signal timing and resource allocation through precise forecasting

  • Random Forest, Support Vector Regression (SVR), and ARIMA for traffic forecasting

  • Gradient boosting as ensemble learning techniques

  • Heat maps to visualize traffic flow distribution

  • Data-driven decision-making integrated into smart city systems

Wang et al. (2023) [45]Urban transport systems (Beijing, China)
  • Low network efficiency due to underutilized stops and poorly connected routes

  • Limited integration between subway and bus systems in traditional network planning

  • Inefficiencies in passenger flow management during peak hours

  • Subway–bus double-layer network model to optimize public transportation routes and connections

  • Structural adjustments to add/remove stops based on demand and efficiency metrics

  • Simulation-driven decision-making to identify areas for network improvement

  • Passenger flow and travel time data derived from IC card swipes

  • Weighted edge connections based on passenger flow and travel time

  • L-space modeling for connectivity analysis and C-space modeling for transfer optimization

  • Gephi for visualization, network efficiency calculations, and complex network analysis

Xu et al. (2023) [46]Urban transport systems (Chattanooga, Tennessee, USA)
  • Cyber–physical traffic control for real-time signal timing optimization

  • Data-driven decision support using traffic simulations and predictive models

  • Interactive dashboards for exploring traffic, safety, and energy metrics

  • Integration of diverse sensors, including Radar Detection Sensors and CCTV cameras, to provide traffic insights

  • Cloud-based infrastructure for large-scale data processing and management

  • Edge computing for distributed data processing at the source to reduce latency and enhance real-time responsiveness

  • Simulation tools for traffic dynamics and energy consumption modeling

  • Modular design ensuring system scalability and interoperability with IoT services

Callefi et al. (2024) [47]Nation-wide transport systems (Brazil)
  • Complexities of freight operations in route planning, resource allocation, and fleet management

  • Need for real-time data sharing and decision-making

  • High environmental impact due to emissions and inefficiencies

  • Technology-driven fleet and route optimization

  • Real-time monitoring for cargo and emission control

  • Enhanced decision-making with integrated data systems

  • IoT sensors, GPS, mobile and wireless communication technologies

  • Cloud computing for data analytics and storage

  • Fuzzy DEMATEL analysis to evaluate interdependencies among capabilities

  • Roadmap development to categorizes capabilities into base (core) and triggered (dependent)

  • Integration of ICT to enhance supply chain management and facilitate strategic decision-making

Dasgupta et al. (2024) [48]Simulated environments (used the real-world traffic data but not specified particular locations)
  • Delays at signalized intersections due to suboptimal traffic signal timing

  • Persistent traffic congestion negatively impacts fuel consumption, emissions, and public health

  • Lack of proactive traffic management tools that adapt to real-time demand

  • Digital twin based adaptive traffic signal control (ATSC) framework for dynamic signal phase optimization

  • Real-time traffic demand prediction and simulation for proactive traffic management

  • Parallel simulations to assess various ATSC algorithms and trade-offs in delay reduction

  • Simulation of real-world traffic flow, including road networks, vehicles, and traffic signals for digital twin

  • Parallel simulations, real-time data integration, and dynamic algorithm selection for the traffic simulation based on the digital twin

  • Data aggregation, synchronization, and visualization

Yang et al. (2024) [49]Nation-wide transport systems (Taiwan)
  • High fatality rates due to recurring violations, such as drunk driving and running red lights

  • Lack of integration between violation data and accident prevention strategies

  • Insufficient use of advanced sensor technologies in accident hotspots

  • Installation of sensor-equipped cameras for real-time monitoring and enforcement

  • Big data analytics to identify accident-prone areas and common violation patterns

  • Enhanced enforcement through predictive models based on historical trends

  • Hadoop distributed file system for splitting and storing large datasets across distributed locations

  • Spark for faster in-memory data processing and trend analysis

  • Tableau for dynamic dashboards and interactive trend analyses

  • LiDAR, CCD cameras, and radar for traffic monitoring



Source link

Heejoo Son www.mdpi.com